"The donut, its spelling betrays its origins, is nearly always more deceit friendly than the pie, despite being modelled on a life-saving ring. This is because the hole destroys the second most important value- defining element, by hiding the slice angles in the middle." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)
"There are some chart types that occasionally appear in print but are so bad that they serve neither honesty nor deceit. Among these monuments to human ingenuity at the expense of common sense are the concentric donut and overlapping segments. The concentric donut is really just a bar or column chart bent back on itself to save space. However as anyone who has ever watched a two or four hundred metre race will know, to make sense of the order of arrival at the tape you have to stagger the start to take account of the bend in the track. Blithely ignoring this problem, the concentric donut uses to diminish the difference between the inner and the outer absolute values by anything up to 2.5 times." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)
"The problem is that a pie chart does one thing well, and most people don’t use it for that one thing. Specifically, they’re great at giving you a fast and accurate estimate of the part-to-whole relationship for two of the slices. Other than that, pie charts are terrible. [...] The same strengths and shortcomings that apply to the pie chart also apply to the donut chart." (Steve Wexler, "The Big Picture: How to use data visualization to make better decisions - faster", 2021)
"Donuts appear to have the advantage over pie charts of allowing for the comparison of multiple series, one in each ring, which makes them the circular version of stacked bar charts. In fact, though, there is little value in this, for it only helps to compare the first and last values of each series, just like the stacked bar chart." (Jorge Camões, "Data at Work: Best practices for creating effective charts and information graphics in Microsoft Excel", 2016)
"A donut chart serves the same purpose as a pie chart, built with the same parameters, with the only difference being the hole (or properly termed, the 'donut hole') in the center. [...] What purpose does the hole serve? Nothing special. We can put the total value there, but there is no such standard option. We can get this result combining two visuals: donut chart and card with total value." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI", 2024)
"[...] a sunburst chart where the center is either a pie chart or a donut chart of the biggest categories surrounded in donuts that show each of the other levels. The outside donut has the leaf nodes [...]" (Nancy Organ, "Data Visualization for People of All Ages", 2024)
"Analysis of the composition of the whole, where the emphasis is not on quantity, but on percentages. It helps to understand which segments and categories contribute the most to the overall result; for example, sales structure by markets, expenditure structure by projects. The basic figure is a circle divided into sectors. Hence the metaphor of 'pie' and 'donut'." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI: How to Design Savvy Dashboards", 2024)
"And here’s another warning - displaying the timeline at the pie or donut. It may seem like a good idea to show quarterly sales shares, and the chart will look neat. But this will distort the meaning: the timeline should be directed horizontally from left to right, from past to future. The same works for any time period: days, months, years. This is a common pattern of perception, and we do not recommend breaking it." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI: How to Design Savvy Dashboards", 2024)
"Pie and donut charts have the same purpose - visualizing the structure for a small number of categories (usually no more than six). These charts are built using the same parameters, with the only difference being that the donut chart has an inner space. They don’t have x-and yaxes, and for customization, you need to follow simple steps." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI", 2024)
"Pie charts, donut charts, and meter charts are really just stacked bar charts that have been bent - but remember that they should always add up to 100%. Radar charts use angle to show categories and position to show amounts. You can also use angle with position to create charts that show movement, direction, or change - on maps and on graphs with number axes, as well as on visualizations with category axes." (Nancy Organ, "Data Visualization for People of All Ages", 2024)
"Treemap is a visualization type used to display hierarchical data in a more structured way than pie or donut charts. In a treemap, rectangles are used instead of sectors. A treemap utilizes space more efficiently and accommodates a larger number of elements." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI", 2024)
"Structure shows which segments and categories contribute the most to the overall result. For visualizing such data, a circle divided into sectors - a pie chart - is usually used. A donut chart has the same meaning, is built on the same parameters, and differs only in the space inside." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI", 2024)
"What’s the difference between them? Studies have shown that they are perceived almost equally. Our eyes gauge the size of the outer arc: a quarter, a third, half, and so on. We surveyed our students and clients to find out which option they prefer. Some say that the ring (donut) looks somehow fresher and more interesting because the pie chart has become boring. But for others, the circle seems clearer. You can choose according to your taste. However, we prefer classic pie charts because they utilize the entire area of the figure for visualization." (Alex Kolokolov & Maxim Zelensky, "Data Visualization with Microsoft Power BI", 2024)
No comments:
Post a Comment