Graphical Representation: Bar & Column Charts (Notes)

Disclaimer: This is work in progress intended to consolidate information from various sources and may deviate from them. Please consult the sources for the exact content!
Last updated: 15-Jun-2024

Bar & Column Charts with Variations

Bar & Column Charts (Graphs) 

• {definition} graphical representation of categorical data with rectangular figures (aka boxes) whose heights (column chart) or lengths (bar chart) are proportional to the values that they represent
• {benefit} allow to visually encode/decode quantitative information-size as magnitude and area based on the relative position of the end of the box along the common scale
• if the width of the box is the same, it's enough to compare the length
• ⇒ the basis of comparison is one-dimensional [1]
• ⇐ orient the reader to the relative magnitudes of the boxes
• area is typically encoded when the width varies
• ⇐ encoding by area is a poor encoding method as it can mislead
• can represent negative and positive values 
• one of the most useful, simple, and adaptable techniques in graphic presentation [1]
• easily understood by readers
• sometimes avoided because they are so common
• almost everything could be a bar chart
• the length of each bar is proportional to the quantity or amount of each category represented [1]
• ⇒the zero line must be shown [1]
• ⇒the scale must not be broken [1]
• {exception} an excessively long bar in a series of bars may be broken off at the end, and the amount involved shown directly beyond it [1]
• {benefit} allow to visually represent categorical data
• ⇒ occasionally represented without scales, grid lines or tick marks
• the more data elements are presented, the more difficult it becomes to navigate and/or display the data
• {benefit} allow us to easily compare magnitudes 
• sometimes without looking at the actual values
• {type} bar chart
• the box is shown horizontally
• represents magnitude by length
• allows comparing different items as of a specific time
• {type} column chart
• the box is shown vertically
• represents magnitude by height
• allows comparing different items over time
• ⇐ it still displays discrete points
• recommended for comparing similar items for different time periods [2]
• effective way to show most types of comparisons [2]
• {subtype} stacked chart
• variation of bar/column charts in which the boxes of a dimension's components are staked over each other
• {exception} spaces can be used between boxes if the values aren't cumulative [3]
• {benefit} allows encoding a further dimension where the values are staked within the same box
• {drawback} do not show data structure well
• ⇒ make it challenging to compare values across boxes
• {subtype} 100-percent chart
• variation of stacked chart in which the magnitude totals to 100%
• {benefit} allows to display part to whole relationships
• ⇐ preferable to circle chart's angle and area comparison [1]
• {subtype} clustered chart (aka grouped chart)
• variation of bar/column charts that allows encoding further quantitative information in distinct boxes tacked together which occasionally overlap
• ⇐ if there's space, it is usually kept to a minimum
• e.g. can be used to display multiple data series 
• can be used with a secondary axis
• {benefit} allows comparisons within the cluster/group as well between clusters/groups
• {drawback} more challenging to make comparisons across points
• {subtype} area chart (variable-width/variwide chart/graph) 
• variation of bar/column charts in which the height/width have significance being proportional to some measure or characteristics of the data elements represented [3]
• {benefit} allow encoding a further dimension as part of the area
• {subtype} deviation chart 
• variation of bar/column charts that display positive and negative values 
• {subtype} joined chart
• variation of bar/column charts in which the boxes are tacked together
• {benefit} allow to better use the space available 
• {subtype} paired chart 
• variation of bar/column charts in which the boxes are paired in mirror based on an axis
• e.g. the values of one data series are displayed to the left, while the values for a second data series are displayed to the right 
• {benefit} allows to study the correlation and/or other relationships between the values of two data series
• the hidden axes can have different scales 
• {subtype} circular chart (aka radial chart)
• variation of bar/column charts in which the boxes are wrapped into a circle, the various categories being uniformly spaced along the radial or category axis [3]
• the value scale can have any upper or lower value and can progress in either direction [3]
• {benefit} useful to represent data that have a circular dimension in an aesthetic form
• e.g. months, hours
• {subtype} waterfall chart (aka progressing chart)
• variation of bar/column charts in which the boxes are displayed progressively, the start of a box corresponding the end of the previous box 
• time and activity charts can be considered as variations of this subtype [3]
• {advantage} allows to determine cumulative values, respectively the increase/decrease between consecutive boxes
• {subtype}composite chart (aka mixed chart, combination chart, overlay chart)
• variation of bar/column charts in besides boxes are used other graphic types of encoding (line, area)
• ⇐ the different data graphics are overlaid on one another [3]
• {benefit} allows to improve clarity or highlight the relationships between several data series [3]
• {drawback} overlaying can result in clutter 
• used to  
• display totals, averages or frequencies
• display time series
• display the relationship between two or more items
• make a comparison among several items
• make a comparison between parts and the whole
• can be confounded with 
• [histograms]
• show distribution through the frequency of quantitative values against defined intervals of quantitative values
• used for continuous numerical data or data that can be effectively modelled as continuous
• it doesn't have spaces between bars
• ⇐ older use of bar/column charts don't use spaces
• if this aspect is ignored, histograms can be considered as a special type of area chart
• [vertical line chart] (aka price chart, bar chart)
• vertical line charts are sometimes referred as bar charts (see [3])
• things to consider
• distance between bars
• the more distant the bars, the more difficult it becomes to make comparisons and the accuracy of judgment decreases
• sorting
• sorting the bars/columns by their size facilitates comparisons, though it can impede items' search, especially when there are many categories involved
• {exception} not recommended for time series
• clutter
• displaying too many items in a cluster and/or too many labels can lead to clutter
• {recommendation} display at maximum 3-4 clustered boxes
• color
• one should follow the general recommendations 
• trend lines
• can be used especially with time series especially to represent the linear regression line
• dual axis
• {benefit} allows to compare the magnitudes of two data series by employing a secondary axis
• overlapping
• overlapping boxes can make charts easier to read
• symbols
• can be used to designate reference points of comparison for each of the bars [3]
• {alternative} pie chart
• can be used to dramatize comparisons in relation to the whole [2]
• one should consider the drawbacks 
• {alternative} choropleth maps
• more adequate for geographical dimensions
• provide minimal encoding 
• {alternative} line charts
• can be much more informative
• provides an optimal dat-ink ratio
• reduces the chart junk feeling
• {alternative} dot plots
• are closer to the original data

References:
[1] Anna C Rogers (1961) "Graphic Charts Handbook"
[2] Robert Lefferts (1981) "Elements of Graphics: How to prepare charts and graphs for effective reports"
[3] Robert L Harris (1996) "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference"