📉Graphical Representation: Space (Just the Quotes)

"The zero of the scale should appear on every chart, and should shown by a heavy line carried across the sheet. If this is not done the reader may assume the bottom of the sheet to be zero and so be misled. The scale should be graduated from zero to a little over the maximum figure to be plotted on the charts, so that there will be a space between the highest peak on the curve and the top of the chart." (Allan C Haskell, "How to Make and Use Graphic Charts", 1919)

"A chart without a border line has several advantages. It is not limited to a designated area. The irregular white space surrounding it makes it more adaptable to any page size. It may be more readily placed either horizontally or vertically on the page, so long as the reduction in the size of the chart does not destroy legibility of lettering." (Mary E Spear, "Charting Statistics", 1952)

"Since the chief purpose of the nomogram is to make exact data available for operational use, its chief competitor is the table. Operational tables may break Ehrenberg's two-digit rule, since they are not used to detect general trends but to provide exact data for some operational purpose. The choice  between nomogram and table involves a complex tradeoff among cost, space, convenience, accuracy, and speed. These tradeoff situations provide one good reason why no one graphic format is suitable for all purposes. Of course, there can be good methods (sarisfying solutions) for particular cases." (Michael Macdonald-Ross, "Graphics in Texts", Review of Research in Education Vol. 5, 1977)

"An especially effective device for enhancing the explanatory power of time-series displays is to add spatial dimensions to the design of the graphic, so that the data are moving over space (in two or three dimensions) as well as over time. […] Occasionally graphics are belligerently multivariate, advertising the technique rather than the data." (Edward R Tufte, "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information", 1983)

"Graphical excellence is the well-designed presentation of interesting data - a matter of substance, of statistics, and of design. Graphical excellence consists of complex ideas communicated with clarity, precision, and efficiency. Graphical excellence is that which gives to the viewer the greatest number of ideas in the shortest time with the least ink in the smallest space. Graphical excellence is nearly always multivariate. And graphical excellence requires telling the truth about the data." (Edward R Tufte, "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information", 1983)

"A time series is a special case of the broader dependent-independent variable category. Time is the independent variable. One important property of most time series is that for each time point of the data there is only a single value of the dependent variable; there are no repeat measurements. Furthermore, most time series are measured at equally-spaced or nearly equally-spaced points in time." (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"Binning has two basic limitations. First, binning sacrifices resolution. Sometimes plots of the raw data will reveal interesting fine structure that is hidden by binning. However, advantages from binning often outweigh the disadvantage from lost resolution. [...] Second, binning does not extend well to high dimensions. With reasonable univariate resolution, say 50 regions each covering 2% of the range of the variable, the number of cells for a mere 10 variables is exceedingly large. For uniformly distributed data, it would take a huge sample size to fill a respectable fraction of the cells. The message is not so much that binning is bad but that high dimensional space is big. The complement to the curse of dimensionality is the blessing of large samples. Even in two and three dimensions having lots of data can bc very helpful when the observations are noisy and the structure non-trivial." (Daniel B Carr, "Looking at Large Data Sets Using Binned Data Plots", [in "Computing and Graphics in Statistics"] 1991)

"Many of the applications of visualization in this book give the impression that data analysis consists of an orderly progression of exploratory graphs, fitting, and visualization of fits and residuals. Coherence of discussion and limited space necessitate a presentation that appears to imply this. Real life is usually quite different. There are blind alleys. There are mistaken actions. There are effects missed until the very end when some visualization saves the day. And worse, there is the possibility of the nearly unmentionable: missed effects." (William S Cleveland, "Visualizing Data", 1993)

"In preparing bar charts, make certain that the space separating the bars is smaller than the width of the bars. Use the most contrasting color or shading to emphasize the important item, thereby reinforcing the message title." (Gene Zelazny. "Say It with Charts: The executive’s guide to visual communication" 4th Ed., 2001)

"The suggestions for making the most of bar charts also apply to column charts: make the space between the columns smaller than the width of the columns; and use color or shading to emphasize one point in time more than others or to distinguish, say, historical from projected data." (Gene Zelazny. "Say It with Charts: The executive’s guide to visual communication" 4th Ed., 2001)

"Coordinates are sets that locate points in space. These sets are usually numbers grouped in tuples, one tuple for each point. Because spaces can be defined as sets of geometric objects plus axioms defining their behavior, coordinates can be thought of more generally as schemes for mapping elements of sets to geometric objects." (Leland Wilkinson, "The Grammar of Graphics" 2nd Ed., 2005)

"[...] the First Principle for the analysis and presentation data: 'Show comparisons, contrasts, differences'. The fundamental analytical act in statistical reasoning is to answer the question "Compared with what?". Whether we are evaluating changes over space or time, searching big data bases, adjusting and controlling for variables, designing experiments , specifying multiple regressions, or doing just about any kind of evidence-based reasoning, the essential point is to make intelligent and appropriate comparisons. Thus visual displays, if they are to assist thinking, should show comparisons." (Edward R Tufte, "Beautiful Evidence", 2006)

"Closely spaced lines produce moiré vibration, usually at its worst when data-lines (the figure) and spaces (the ground) between data-lines are approximately equal in size, and also when figure and ground contrast strongly in color value." (Edward R Tufte, "Beautiful Evidence", 2006)

"Most techniques for displaying evidence are inherently multimodal, bringing verbal, visual. and quantitative elements together. Statistical graphics and maps arc visual-numerical fields labeled with words and framed by numbers. Even an austere image may evoke other images, new or remembered narrative, and perhaps a sense of scale and quantity. Words can simultaneously convey semantic and visual content, as the nouns on a map both name places and locate them in the two - space of latitude and longitude." (Edward R Tufte, "Beautiful Evidence", 2006)

"The notion of outcomes covering a space is a very useful mental image, as it ties in strongly with the use of Venn diagrams and tables for clarifying the nature of possible events resulting from a trial. There are two important aspects to this. First, when enumerating the various outcomes that comprise an event, the number of (equally. likely) outcomes should correspond, visually, with the area of that part of the diagram represented by the event in question - the greater the probability, the larger the area. Secondly, where events overlap (for example, when rolling a die, consider the two events 'getting an even score' and 'getting a score greater than 2' ), the various regions in the Venn diagram help to clarify the various combinations of events that might occur." (Alan Graham, "Developing Thinking in Statistics", 2006)

"Radar charts are almost always the result either of space-saving attempts or of doubtful theories about the desirability of 'symmetrical' plots, in which scores on all dimensions are similar, so giving an approximation to a circle. Their scales offer unlimited scope for manipulation in achieving this lunatic ambition." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"There are some chart types that occasionally appear in print but are so bad that they serve neither honesty nor deceit. Among these monuments to human ingenuity at the expense of common sense are the concentric donut and overlapping segments. The concentric donut is really just a bar or column chart bent back on itself to save space. However as anyone who has ever watched a two or four hundred metre race will know, to make sense of the order of arrival at the tape you have to stagger the start to take account of the bend in the track. Blithely ignoring this problem, the concentric donut uses to diminish the difference between the inner and the outer absolute values by anything up to 2.5 times." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"Mosaic plots become more difficult to read for variables with more than two or three categories. One way out is to assign a constant space for all possible crossings of categories. This way, the data from the r×c table are plotted in a table-like layout. Whereas this regular layout makes it much easier to compare values across rows and columns, the plot space is used less efficiently than in a mosaic plot." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009)

"One big advantage of parallel coordinate plots over scatterplot matrices. (i.e., the matrix of scatterplots of all variable pairs) is that parallel coordinate plots need less space to plot the same amount of data. On the other hand, parallel coordinate plots with p variables show only p − 1 adjacencies. However, adjacent variables reveal most of the information in a parallel coordinate plot. Reordering variables in a parallel coordinate plot is therefore essential." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009) 

"Shingling is the process of dividing a continuous variable into - possibly overlapping - intervals in order to convert a continuous variable into a discrete variable. Shingling is quite different from conditioning on categorical variables. Overlapping shingles/intervals lead to multiple representation of data within a trellis display, which is not the case for categorical variables. Furthermore, it is challenging to judge which intervals/cases have been chosen to build a shingle. Trellis displays represent the shingle interval visually by an interval of the strip label. Although no plotting space is wasted, the information on the intervals is difficult to read from the strip label. Despite these drawbacks, there is a valid motivation for shingling […]." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009) 

"The data [in tables] should not be so spaced out that it is difficult to follow or so cramped that it looks trapped. Keep columns close together; do not spread them out more than is necessary. If the columns must be spread out to fit a particular area, such as the width of a page, use a graphic device such as a line or screen to guide the reader’s eye across the row." (Dennis K Lieu & Sheryl Sorby, "Visualization, Modeling, and Graphics for Engineering Design", 2009)

"Trellis displays introduce the concept of shingling. Shingling is the process of dividing a continuous variable into - possibly overlapping - intervals in order to convert a continuous variable into a discrete variable. Shingling is quite different from conditioning on categorical variables. Overlapping shingles/intervals lead to multiple representation of data within a trellis display, which is not the case for categorical variables. Furthermore, it is challenging to judge which intervals/cases have been chosen to build a shingle. Trellis displays represent the shingle interval visually by an interval of the strip label. Although no plotting space is wasted, the information on the intervals is difficult to read from the strip label. Despite these drawbacks, there is a valid motivation for shingling," (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009)

"Be aware that bar charts provide ample opportunities for chart junk. The space within the bars is enticingly empty and it is tempting to put images or textures in the background. Some designers even swap out the standard bars for graphics." (Brian Suda, "A Practical Guide to Designing with Data", 2010)

"The amount of information rendered in a single financial graph is easily equivalent to thousands of words of text or a page-sized table of raw values. A graph illustrates so many characteristics of data in a much smaller space than any other means. Charts also allow us to tell a story in a quick and easy way that words cannot." (Brian Suda, "A Practical Guide to Designing with Data", 2010)

"Sparklines aren't necessarily a variation on the line chart, rather, a clever use of them. [...] They take advantage of our visual perception capabilities to discriminate changes even at such a low resolution in terms of size. They facilitate opportunities to construct particularly dense visual displays of data in small space and so are particularly applicable for use on dashboards." (Andy Kirk, "Data Visualization: A successful design process", 2012)

"Area can also make data seem more tangible or relatable, because physical objects take up space. A circle or a square uses more space than a dot on a screen or paper. There’s less abstraction between visual cue and real world." (Nathan Yau, "Data Points: Visualization That Means Something", 2013)

"A space-filling layout has the property that it fills all available space in the view, as the name implies. [...] ne advantage of space-filling approaches is that they maximize the amount of room available for color coding, increasing the chance that the colored region will be large enough to be perceptually salient to the viewer. A related advantage is that the available space representing an item is often large enough to show a label embedded within it, rather than needing more room off to the side. In contrast, one disadvantage of space-filling views is that the designer cannot make use of white space in the layout; that is, empty space where there are no explicit visual elements. Many graphic design guidelines pertain to the careful use of white space for many reasons, including readability, emphasis, relative importance, and visual balance." (Tamara Munzner, "Visualization Analysis and Design", 2014)

"As with all design problems, vis design cannot be easily handled as a simple process of optimization because trade-offs abound. A design that does well by one measure will rate poorly on another. The characterization of trade-offs in the vis design space is a very open problem at the frontier of vis research." (Tamara Munzner, "Visualization Analysis and Design", 2014)

"Parallel coordinates visually encode data using two dimensions of spatial position. Of course, any individual axis requires only one spatial dimension, but the second dimension is used to lay out multiple axes. The scalability is high in terms of the number of quantitative attribute values that can be discriminated, since the high precisionchannel of planar spatial position is used. The exact number is roughly proportional to the screen space extent of the axes, in pixels. The scalability is moderate in terms of number of attributes that can be displayed: dozens is common. As the number of attributes shown increases, so does the width required to display them, so a parallel coordinates display showing many attributes is typically a wide and flat rectangle. Assuming that the axes are vertical, then the amount of vertical screen space required to distinguish position along them does not change, but the amount of horizontal screen space increases as more axes are added. One limit is that there must be enough room between the axes to discern the patterns of intersection or parallelism of the line  segments that pass between them." (Tamara Munzner, "Visualization Analysis and Design", 2014)

"Decision trees are also discriminative models. Decision trees are induced by recursively partitioning the feature space into regions belonging to the different classes, and consequently they define a decision boundary by aggregating the neighboring regions belonging to the same class. Decision tree model ensembles based on bagging and boosting are also discriminative models." (John D Kelleher et al, "Fundamentals of Machine Learning for Predictive Data Analytics: Algorithms, Worked Examples, and Case Studies", 2015)

"One thing to keep in mind with a table is that you want the design to fade into the background, letting the data take center stage. Don’t let heavy borders or shading compete for attention. Instead, think of using light borders or simply white space to set apart elements of the table." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"When we’re at the point of communicating our analysis to our audience, we really want to be in the explanatory space, meaning you have a specific thing you want to explain, a specific story you want to tell - probably about those two pearls." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"Linking is a powerful dynamic interactive graphics technique that can help us better understand high-dimensional data. This technique works in the following way: When several plots are linked, selecting an observation's point in a plot will do more than highlight the observation in the plot we are interacting with - it will also highlight points in other plots with which it is linked, giving us a more complete idea of its value across all the variables. Selecting is done interactively with a pointing device. The point selected, and corresponding points in the other linked plots, are highlighted simultaneously. Thus, we can select a cluster of points in one plot and see if it corresponds to a cluster in any other plot, enabling us to investigate the high-dimensional shape and density of the cluster of points, and permitting us to investigate the structure of the disease space." (Forrest W Young et al, "Visual Statistics: Seeing data with dynamic interactive graphics", 2016)

"A time series is a sequence of values, usually taken in equally spaced intervals. […] Essentially, anything with a time dimension, measured in regular intervals, can be used for time series analysis." (Andy Kriebel & Eva Murray, "#MakeoverMonday: Improving How We Visualize and Analyze Data, One Chart at a Time", 2018)

"Ideally, the charts are designed in a way that gives your audience clarity and lets them understand the key insights very quickly. Color choices, highlighting, annotations, and other ways of drawing attention to your findings help in the process. By leaving white or blank space around your charts, you are able to keep the focus of your audience on the key message rather than distracting or confusing them." (Andy Kriebel & Eva Murray, "#MakeoverMonday: Improving How We Visualize and Analyze Data, One Chart at a Time", 2018)

"Simplicity in design can be recognized in visualizations that are clear, easy to understand, uncluttered, and impactful. Nonessential items are removed from these visualizations so that the data stands out, giving it space and removing distractions. Simplicity in design pays careful attention to the overall layout and positioning of individual components, the balance of charts and text elements, and the choice of colors, fonts, and icons, as well as the clarity with which all of these elements communicate to the audience." (Andy Kriebel & Eva Murray, "#MakeoverMonday: Improving How We Visualize and Analyze Data, One Chart at a Time", 2018)

"The radial bar chart, also called the polar bar chart, arranges the bars to radiate outward from the center of a circle. This graph lies lowers on the perceptual ranking list because it is harder to compare the heights of the bars arranged around a circle than when they are arranged along a single flat axis. But this layout does allow you to fit more values in a compact space, and makes the radial bar chart well-suited for showing more data, frequent changes (such as monthly or daily), or changes over a long period of time." (Jonathan Schwabish, "Better Data Visualizations: A guide for scholars, researchers, and wonks", 2021)

"A semantic approach to visualization focuses on the interplay between charts, not just the selection of charts themselves. The approach unites the structural content of charts with the context and knowledge of those interacting with the composition. It avoids undue and excessive repetition by instead using referential devices, such as filtering or providing detail-on-demand. A cohesive analytical conversation also builds guardrails to keep users from derailing from the conversation or finding themselves lost without context. Functional aesthetics around color, sequence, style, use of space, alignment, framing, and other visual encodings can affect how users follow the script." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"Like multimodal reading, data literacy relies on both primary literacy skills and numeracy skills to truly make sense of the third layer: reading and understanding graphs. Charts codify numbers visually into parameters, using stylized marks to embed additional layers of meaning and space to provide quantitative relationships. Beyond the individual chart, data visualizations create ensembles of charts." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"Maps are a type of chart that can convey relationships about space and relationships between objects that we relate to in the real world. Their effectiveness as a communication medium is strongly influenced by a host of factors: the nature of spatial data, the form and structure of representation, their intended purpose, the experience of the audience, and the context in the time and space in which the map is viewed. In other words, maps are a ubiquitous representation of spatial information that we can understand and relate to." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"Positive and negative space help create balance, but they also draw interest." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"The sizes of charts in space reflect how we convey information to a reader. In a dashboard context, the content, size, and space that the various charts occupy should reflect the form and function of the main message. As you saw with the bento box metaphor from the introduction, there needs to be deliberate thought put into the placement and size of each individual chart so that they all work together in harmony." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

📉Graphical Representation: Pitfalls (Just the Quotes)

Disclaimer: the following quotes are intended as a list of the things to avoid in Graphical Representation. For the full quotes see the previous post

"[...] avoid complicating the diagram by including too much data." (Armand Julin, "Summary for a Course of Statistics, General and Applied", 1910) 

"In general, the comparison of two circles of different size should be strictly avoided." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"Try telling the story in words different from those on the charts. […] If the chart shows a picture, describe the picture. Tell what it shows and why it is shown. If it is a diagram, explain it. Don't leave the audience to figure it out." (Edward J Hegarty, "How to Use a Set of Display Charts", The American Statistician Vol. 2" (5), 1948)

"It is not enough to avoid outright falsehood; one must be on the alert to detect possible distortion of truth." (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"[...] avoid distortion or misrepresentation." (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"The designer normally should place no more than three data paths on the graph to prevent confusion - particularly if the data paths intersect at one or more points on the Cartesian plane." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"There are two kinds of misrepresentation. In one, the numerical data do not agree with the data in the graph, or certain relevant data are omitted. This kind of misleading presentation, while perhaps hard to determine, clearly is wrong and can be avoided. In the second kind of misrepresentation, the meaning of the data is different to the preparer and to the user." (Anker V Andersen, "Graphing Financial Information: How accountants can use graphs to communicate", 1983)

"Do not allow data labels in the data region to interfere with the quantitative data or to clutter the graph. […] Avoid putting notes, keys, and markers in the data region. Put keys and markers just outside the data region and put notes in the legend or in the text." (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"Make the data stand out and avoid superfluity are two broad strategies that serve as an overall guide to the specific principles. " (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"Shorten long labels; avoid abbreviations unless they are universally understood; avoid repetition on the same graph." (Mary H Briscoe, "Preparing Scientific Illustrations: A guide to better posters, presentations, and publications" 2nd ed., 1995) 

"[...] avoid those graphical features that are purely decorative [...]" (Phillip I Good & James W Hardin, "Common Errors in Statistics" (and How to Avoid Them)", 2003)

"[...] avoid useless graphics." (Jacques Bertin [interview], 2003)

"If a break cannot be avoided, use a full scale break." (Naomi B Robbins, "Creating More effective Graphs", 2005)

"[...] when labels abandon the data points, then a code is often needed to relink names to numbers. Such codes, keys, and legends are impediments to learning, causing the reader's brow to furrow." (Edward R Tufte, "Beautiful Evidence", 2006) [argumentation against Cleveland's recommendation of not using words on data plots]

"Generally pie charts are to be avoided, as they can be difficult to interpret particularly when the number of categories is greater than five." (Jenny Freeman et al, "How to Display Data", 2008)

"Spurious precision should be avoided although when certain measures are to be used for further calculations or when presenting the results of analyses, greater precision may sometimes be appropriate." (Jenny Freeman et al, "How to Display Data", 2008)

"The data [in tables] should not be so spaced out that it is difficult to follow or so cramped that it looks trapped. Keep columns close together; do not spread them out more than is necessary." (Dennis K Lieu & Sheryl Sorby, "Visualization, Modeling, and Graphics for Engineering Design", 2009)

"[...] it is often best to avoid round charts and graphs." (Brian Suda, "A Practical Guide to Designing with Data", 2010)

"Avoid countering conventions where possible in order to avoid creating cognitive dissonance, a clash of habitual interpretation with the underlying message you are sending." (Noah Iliinsky & Julie Steel, "Designing Data Visualizations", 2011)

"The unseen data may be just as important, or even more important, than the seen data. To avoid survivor bias, start in the past and look forward." (Gary Smith, "Standard Deviations", 2014)

"Highlighting one aspect can make other things harder to see one word of warning in using preattentive attributes: when you highlight one point in your story, it can actually make other points harder to see. When you’re doing exploratory analysis, you should mostly avoid the use of preattentive attributes for this reason." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"Collecting data through sampling therefore becomes a never-ending battle to avoid sources of bias. [...] While trying to obtain a random sample, researchers sometimes make errors in judgment about whether every person or thing is equally likely to be sampled." (Daniel J Levitin, "Weaponized Lies", 2017)

"[...] avoid pure colors that are bright and saturated." (Kate Strachnyi, "ColorWise: A Data Storyteller’s Guide to the Intentional Use of Color", 2023)

📉Graphical Representation: Taboos (Just the Quotes)

"The essential quality of graphic representations is clarity. If the diagram fails to give a clearer impression than the tables of figures it replaces, it is useless. To this end, we will avoid complicating the diagram by including too much data." (Armand Julin, "Summary for a Course of Statistics, General and Applied", 1910)

"Comparison between circles of different size should be absolutely avoided. It is inexcusable when we have available simple methods of charting so good and so convenient from every point of view as the horizontal bar." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"In general, the comparison of two circles of different size should be strictly avoided. Many excellent works on statistics approve the comparison of circles of different size, and state that the circles should always be drawn to represent the facts on an area basis rather than on a diameter basis. The rule, however, is not always followed and the reader has no way of telling whether the circles compared have been drawn on a diameter basis or on an area basis, unless the actual figures for the data are given so that the dimensions may be verified." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"Judgment must be used in the showing of figures in any chart or numerical presentation, so that the figures may not give an appearance of greater accuracy than their method of collection would warrant. Too many otherwise excellent reports contain figures which give the impression of great accuracy when in reality the figures may be only the crudest approximations. Except in financial statements, it is a safe rule to use ciphers whenever possible at the right of all numbers of great size. The use of the ciphers greatly simplifies the grasping of the figures by the reader, and, at the same time, it helps to avoid the impression of an accuracy which is not warranted by the methods of collecting the data." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"Many people use statistics as a drunkard uses a street lamp - for support rather than illumination. It is not enough to avoid outright falsehood; one must be on the alert to detect possible distortion of truth. One can hardly pick up a newspaper without seeing some sensational headline based on scanty or doubtful data." (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"Simplicity, accuracy, appropriate size, proper proportion, correct emphasis, and skilled execution - these are the factors that produce the effective chart. To achieve simplicity your chart must be designed with a definite audience in mind, show only essential information. Technical terms should be absent as far as possible. And in case of doubt it is wiser to oversimplify than to make matters unduly complex. Be careful to avoid distortion or misrepresentation. Accuracy in graphics is more a matter of portraying a clear reliable picture than reiterating exact values. Selecting the right scales and employing authoritative titles and legends are as important as precision plotting. The right size of a chart depends on its probable use, its importance, and the amount of detail involved." (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"If two or more data paths ate to appear on the graph. it is essential that these lines be labeled clearly, or at least a reference should be provided for the reader to make the necessary identifications. While clarity seems to be a most obvious goal. graphs with inadequate or confusing labeling do appear in publications, The user should not find identification of data paths troublesome or subject to misunderstanding. The designer normally should place no more than three data paths on the graph to prevent confusion - particularly if the data paths intersect at one or more points on the Cartesian plane." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"There are two kinds of misrepresentation. In one, the numerical data do not agree with the data in the graph, or certain relevant data are omitted. This kind of misleading presentation, while perhaps hard to determine, clearly is wrong and can be avoided. In the second kind of misrepresentation, the meaning of the data is different to the preparer and to the user." (Anker V Andersen, "Graphing Financial Information: How accountants can use graphs to communicate", 1983)

"Do not allow data labels in the data region to interfere with the quantitative data or to clutter the graph. […] Avoid putting notes, keys, and markers in the data region. Put keys and markers just outside the data region and put notes in the legend or in the text." (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"Make the data stand out and avoid superfluity are two broad strategies that serve as an overall guide to the specific principles […] The data - the quantitative and qualitative information in the data region - are the reason for the existence of the graph. The data should stand out. […] We should eliminate superfluity in graphs. Unnecessary parts of a graph add to the clutter and increase the difficulty of making the necessary elements - the data - stand out." (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"Labels should be complete but succinct. Long and complicated labels will defeat the viewer and therefore the purpose of the graph. Treat a label as a cue to jog the memory or to complete comprehension. Shorten long labels; avoid abbreviations unless they are universally understood; avoid repetition on the same graph. A title, for instance, should not repeat what is already in the axis labels. Be consistent in terminology." (Mary H Briscoe, "Preparing Scientific Illustrations: A guide to better posters, presentations, and publications" 2nd ed., 1995)

"Principal components and factor analysis are methods for data reduction. They seek a few underlying dimensions that account for patterns of variation among the observed variables underlying dimensions imply ways to combine variables, simplifying subsequent analysis. For example, a few combined variables could replace many original variables in a regression. Advantages of this approach include more parsimonious models, improved measurement of indirectly observed concepts, new graphical displays, and the avoidance of multicollinearity." (Lawrence C Hamilton, "Regression with Graphics: A second course in applied statistics", 1991)

"Graphical illustrations should be simple and pleasing to the eye, but the presentation must remain scientific. In other words, we want to avoid those graphical features that are purely decorative while keeping a critical eye open for opportunities to enhance the scientific inference we expect from the reader. A good graphical design should maximize the proportion of the ink used for communicating scientific information in the overall display." (Phillip I Good & James W Hardin, "Common Errors in Statistics" (and How to Avoid Them)", 2003)

"These questions can be applied to every kind of problem. They measure the usefulness of whatever construction or graphical invention allowing you to avoid useless graphics." (Jacques Bertin [interview], 2003)

"Use a scale break only when necessary. If a break cannot be avoided, use a full scale break. Taking logs can cure the need for a break." (Naomi B Robbins, "Creating More effective Graphs", 2005)

"Conflicting with the idea of integrating evidence regardless of its these guidelines provoke several issues: First, labels are data. even intriguing data. [...] Second, when labels abandon the data points, then a code is often needed to relink names to numbers. Such codes, keys, and legends are impediments to learning, causing the reader's brow to furrow. Third, segregating nouns from data-dots breaks up evidence on the basis of mode" (verbal vs. nonverbal), a distinction lacking substantive relevance. Such separation is uncartographic; contradicting the methods of map design often causes trouble for any type of graphical display. Fourth, design strategies that reduce data-resolution take evidence displays in the wrong direction. Fifth, what clutter? Even this supposedly cluttered graph clearly shows the main ideas: brain and body mass are roughly linear in logarithms, and as both variables increase, this linearity becomes less tight." (Edward R Tufte, "Beautiful Evidence", 2006) [argumentation against Cleveland's recommendation of not using words on data plots]

"Generally pie charts are to be avoided, as they can be difficult to interpret particularly when the number of categories is greater than five. Small proportions can be very hard to discern […] In addition, unless the percentages in each of the individual categories are given as numbers it can be much more diff i cult to estimate them from a pie chart than from a bar chart […]." (Jenny Freeman et al, "How to Display Data", 2008)

"Numerical precision should be consistent throughout and summary statistics such as means and standard deviations should not have more than one extra decimal place" (or significant digit) compared to the raw data. Spurious precision should be avoided although when certain measures are to be used for further calculations or when presenting the results of analyses, greater precision may sometimes be appropriate." (Jenny Freeman et al, "How to Display Data", 2008)

"The data [in tables] should not be so spaced out that it is difficult to follow or so cramped that it looks trapped. Keep columns close together; do not spread them out more than is necessary. If the columns must be spread out to fit a particular area, such as the width of a page, use a graphic device such as a line or screen to guide the reader’s eye across the row." (Dennis K Lieu & Sheryl Sorby, "Visualization, Modeling, and Graphics for Engineering Design", 2009)

"Dealing with a circular visualization and trying to compare its radial portions is always problematic. When designing with data, the story should always be told as clearly as possible. To do so, it is often best to avoid round charts and graphs." (Brian Suda, "A Practical Guide to Designing with Data", 2010)

"[...] you should not rely on social or cultural conventions to convey information. However, these conventions can be very powerful, and you should be aware that your reader brings them to the table. Making use of them, when possible, to reinforce your message will help you convey information efficiently. Avoid countering conventions where possible in order to avoid creating cognitive dissonance, a clash of habitual interpretation with the underlying message you are sending." (Noah Iliinsky & Julie Steel, "Designing Data Visualizations", 2011)

"We naturally draw conclusions from what we see […]. We should also think about what we do not see […]. The unseen data may be just as important, or even more important, than the seen data. To avoid survivor bias, start in the past and look forward." (Gary Smith, "Standard Deviations", 2014)

"Highlighting one aspect can make other things harder to see one word of warning in using preattentive attributes: when you highlight one point in your story, it can actually make other points harder to see. When you’re doing exploratory analysis, you should mostly avoid the use of preattentive attributes for this reason. When it comes to explanatory analysis, however, you should have a specific story you are communicating to your audience. Leverage preattentive attributes to help make that story visually clear." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"My base color is grey, not black, to allow for greater contrast since color stands out more against grey than black. For my attention-grabbing color, I often use blue for a number of reasons: (1) I like it, (2) you avoid issues of colorblindness that we’ll discuss momentarily, and (3) it prints well in black-and-white. That said, blue is certainly not your only option (and you’ll see many examples where I deviate from my typical blue for various reasons)." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"Sometimes bar charts are avoided because they are common. This is a mistake. Rather, bar charts should be leveraged because they are common, as this means less of a learning curve for your audience." (Cole N Knaflic, "Storytelling with Data: A Data Visualization Guide for Business Professionals", 2015)

"Effective data scientists know that they are trying to convey accurate information in an easily understood way. We have never seen a pie chart that was an improvement over a simple table. Even worse, the creative addition of pictures, colors, shading, blots, and splotches may produce chartjunk that confuses the reader and strains the eyes." (Gary Smith & Jay Cordes, "The 9 Pitfalls of Data Science", 2019)

"A semantic approach to visualization focuses on the interplay between charts, not just the selection of charts themselves. The approach unites the structural content of charts with the context and knowledge of those interacting with the composition. It avoids undue and excessive repetition by instead using referential devices, such as filtering or providing detail-on-demand. A cohesive analytical conversation also builds guardrails to keep users from derailing from the conversation or finding themselves lost without context. Functional aesthetics around color, sequence, style, use of space, alignment, framing, and other visual encodings can affect how users follow the script." (Vidya Setlur & Bridget Cogley, "Functional Aesthetics for data visualization", 2022)

"One tip to keep an audience focused on your story without overwhelming them is to reduce the saturation of the colors [...] When you lower the brightness and intensity, you are reducing the cognitive load that your audience has to bear. [...] Regardless of what combinations you decide on, you need to avoid pure colors that are bright and saturated." (Kate Strachnyi, "ColorWise: A Data Storyteller’s Guide to the Intentional Use of Color", 2023)

📉Graphical Representation: Qualitative vs. Quantitative (Just the Quotes)

"A model is a qualitative or quantitative representation of a process or endeavor that shows the effects of those factors which are significant for the purposes being considered. A model may be pictorial, descriptive, qualitative, or generally approximate in nature; or it may be mathematical and quantitative in nature and reasonably precise. It is important that effective means for modeling be understood such as analog, stochastic, procedural, scheduling, flow chart, schematic, and block diagrams." (Harold Chestnut, "Systems Engineering Tools", 1965)

"An organization chart is a graphic device that uses pictorial methods to show qualitative information about an organization. [...] The organization chart can be used to show one or more of three things: (1) What the various staff positions in the organization are, how they are structurally related to each other and the span of control and chain of command within the organization. (2) What the different units of the organization are and how they are arranged and related to each other. (3) What the various functions are within the organization and how they are organized and related." (Robert Lefferts, "Elements of Graphics: How to prepare charts and graphs for effective reports", 1981)

"Graphic charts are ways of presenting quantitative as well as qualitative information in an efficient and effective visual form. Numbers and ideas presented graphically are often more easily understood. remembered. and integrated than when they are presented in narrative or tabular form. Descriptions. trends. relationships, and comparisons can be made more apparent. Less time is required to present and comprehend information when graphic methods are employed. As the old truism states, 'One picture is worth a thousand words.'" (Robert Lefferts, "Elements of Graphics: How to prepare charts and graphs for effective reports", 1981)

"Make the data stand out and avoid superfluity are two broad strategies that serve as an overall guide to the specific principles […] The data - the quantitative and qualitative information in the data region - are the reason for the existence of the graph. The data should stand out. […] We should eliminate superfluity in graphs. Unnecessary parts of a graph add to the clutter and increase the difficulty of making the necessary elements - the data - stand out." (William S Cleveland, "The Elements of Graphing Data", 1985)

"There is a technical difference between a bar chart and a histogram in that the number represented is proportional to the length of bar in the former and the area in the latter. This matters if non-uniform binning is used. Bar charts can be used for qualitative or quantitative data, whereas histograms can only be used for quantitative data, as no meaning can be attached to the width of the bins if the data are qualitative." (Roger J Barlow, "Statistics: A guide to the use of statistical methods in the physical sciences", 1989)

"A combination of graphical and tabular presentations may be used to good advantage. The former illustrates most effectively qualitative characteristics (e.g., changes of data with time or sequence) while the latter is the best means to present quantitative information." (Cheryl Cihon & John K Taylor, "Statistical Techniques for Data Analysis" 2nd. ed., 2005)

"We need [graphic] techniques because figures do not speak for them. selves. Numbers alone seldom make a convincing case or polish their author's image - the twin goals of that other great mind bender, rhetoric. While rhetoric deals in qualitative argument, its quantitative equivalent is graphics. As rhetoric has declined in popularity, so graphics have risen along with our acceptance of quantitative arguments. In graphics, figures finally find their own means of expression." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"Diagrams are information graphics that are made up primarily of geometric shapes, such as rectangles, circles, diamonds, or triangles, that are typically" (but not always) interconnected by lines or arrows. One of the major purposes of a diagram is to show how things, people, ideas, activities, etc. interrelate and interconnect. Unlike quantitative charts and graphs, diagrams are used to show interrelationships in a qualitative way." (Robbie T Nakatsu, "Diagrammatic Reasoning in AI", 2010)

"Data analytics is a powerful tool to increase the likelihood that you have the right problem. Both quantitative and qualitative data serve a purpose in supporting a hypothesis. They allow you to objectively measure and identify patterns and relationships." (Shonna D Watters et al, "The Practical Guide for HR Analytics: Using data to inform, transform, and empower HR decisions", 2019)

"The one unique characteristic that separates a data story from other types of stories is its fundamental basis in data. [...] The building blocks of every data story are quantitative or qualitative data, which are frequently the results of an analysis or insightful observation. Because each data story is formed from a collection of facts, each one represents a work of nonfiction. While some creativity may be used in how the story is structured and delivered, a true data story won’t stray too far from its factual underpinnings. In addition, the quality and trustworthiness of the data will determine how credible and powerful the data story is." (Brent Dykes, "Effective Data Storytelling: How to Drive Change with Data, Narrative and Visuals", 2019)

📉Graphical Representation: Statistics (Just the Quotes)

"Graphical statistics can be defined as: 'the expression of statistical facts by means of geometric processes' (Levasseur). Its general usefulness consists of replacing figures which, by their multiplicity, confuse memory, with a figure whose general appearance can be discovered all at once and, by speaking to the eyes, is more easily engraved in the memory." (Armand Julin, "Summary for a Course of Statistics, General and Applied", 1910)

"Although, the tabular arrangement is the fundamental form for presenting a statistical series, a graphic representation - in a chart or diagram - is often of great aid in the study and reporting of statistical facts. Moreover, sometimes statistical data must be taken, in their sources, from graphic rather than tabular records." (William L Crum et al, "Introduction to Economic Statistics", 1938)

"The primary purpose of a graph is to show diagrammatically how the values of one of two linked variables change with those of the other. One of the most useful applications of the graph occurs in connection with the representation of statistical data." (John F Kenney & E S Keeping, "Mathematics of Statistics" Vol. I 3rd Ed., 1954)

"When numbers in tabular form are taboo and words will not do the work well as is often the case. There is one answer left: Draw a picture. About the simplest kind of statistical picture or graph, is the line variety. It is very useful for showing trends, something practically everybody is interested in showing or knowing about or spotting or deploring or forecasting." (Darell Huff, "How to Lie with Statistics", 1954)

"Indeed the language of statistics is rarely as objective as we imagine. The way statistics are presented, their arrangement in a particular way in tables, the juxtaposition of sets of figures, in itself reflects the judgment of the author about what is significant and what is trivial in the situation which the statistics portray." (Ely Devons, "Essays in Economics", 1961)

"[…] an outlier is an observation that lies an 'abnormal' distance from other values in a batch of data. There are two possible explanations for the occurrence of an outlier. One is that this happens to be a rare but valid data item that is either extremely large or extremely small. The other is that it isa mistake – maybe due to A good rule of thumb for deciding how long the analysis of the data actually will take is (1) to add up all the time for everything you can think of - editing the data, checking for errors, calculating various statistics, thinking about the results, going back to the data to try out a new idea, and (2) then multiply the estimate obtained in this first step by five." (Edward R Tufte, "Data Analysis for Politics and Policy", 1974)

"Statistical techniques do not solve any of the common-sense difficulties about making causal inferences. Such techniques may help organize or arrange the data so that the numbers speak more clearly to the question of causality - but that is all statistical techniques can do. All the logical, theoretical, and empirical difficulties attendant to establishing a causal relationship persist no matter what type of statistical analysis is applied." (Edward R Tufte, "Data Analysis for Politics and Policy", 1974)

"Just like the spoken or written word, statistics and graphs can lie. They can lie by not telling the full story. They can lead to wrong conclusions by omitting some of the important facts. [...] Always look at statistics with a critical eye, and you will not be the victim of misleading information." (Dyno Lowenstein, "Graphs", 1976)

"Learning to make graphs involves two things: (l) the techniques of plotting statistics, which might be called the artist's job; and" (2) understanding the statistics. When you know how to work out graphs, all kinds of statistics will probably become more interesting to you." (Dyno Lowenstein, "Graphs", 1976)

"Of course, statistical graphics, just like statistical calculations, are only as good as what goes into them. An ill-specified or preposterous model or a puny data set cannot be rescued by a graphic (or by calculation), no matter how clever or fancy. A silly theory means a silly graphic." (Edward R Tufte, "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information", 1983)

"Statistics is a tool. In experimental science you plan and carry out experiments, and then analyse and interpret the results. To do this you use statistical arguments and calculations. Like any other tool - an oscilloscope, for example, or a spectrometer, or even a humble spanner - you can use it delicately or clumsily, skillfully or ineptly. The more you know about it and understand how it works, the better you will be able to use it and the more useful it will be." (Roger J Barlow, "Statistics: A guide to the use of statistical methods in the physical sciences", 1989)

"There is an interplay between statistical models and graphics, so it is advantageous to think about models before making a series of plots." (Daniel B Carr, "Looking at Large Data Sets Using Binned Data Plots", [in "Computing and Graphics in Statistics"] 1991)

"There are two components to visualizing the structure of statistical data - graphing and fitting. Graphs are needed, of course, because visualization implies a process in which information is encoded on visual displays. Fitting mathematical functions to data is needed too. Just graphing raw data, without fitting them and without graphing the fits and residuals, often leaves important aspects of data undiscovered." (William S Cleveland, "Visualizing Data", 1993)

"But people treat mutant statistics just as they do other statistics - that is, they usually accept even the most implausible claims without question. [...] And people repeat bad statistics [...] bad statistics live on; they take on lives of their own. [...] Statistics, then, have a bad reputation. We suspect that statistics may be wrong, that people who use statistics may be 'lying' - trying to manipulate us by using numbers to somehow distort the truth. Yet, at the same time, we need statistics; we depend upon them to summarize and clarify the nature of our complex society. This is particularly true when we talk about social problems." (Joel Best, "Damned Lies and Statistics: Untangling Numbers from the Media, Politicians, and Activists", 2001)

"Every statistical analysis is an interpretation of the data, and missingness affects the interpretation. The challenge is that when the reasons for the missingness cannot be determined there is basically no way to make appropriate statistical adjustments. Sensitivity analyses are designed to model and explore a reasonable range of explanations in order to assess the robustness of the results." (Gerald van Belle, "Statistical Rules of Thumb", 2002)

"Estimating the missing values in a dataset solves one problem - imputing reasonable values that have well-defined statistical properties. It fails to solve another, however - drawing inferences about parameters in a model fit to the estimated data. Treating imputed values as if they were known (like the rest of the observed data) causes confidence intervals to be too narrow and tends to bias other estimates that depend on the variability of the imputed values (such as correlations)." (Leland Wilkinson, "The Grammar of Graphics" 2nd Ed., 2005)

"The consequence of distinguishing statistical methods from the graphics displaying them is to separate form from function. That is, the same statistic can be represented by different types of graphics, and the same type of graphic can be used to display two different statistics. […] This separability of statistical and geometric objects is what gives a system a wide range of representational opportunities." (Leland Wilkinson, "The Grammar of Graphics" 2nd Ed., 2005)

"Statistics has its own basic suite of domain-specific visualization tools. These statistical graphics can best be classified by the kind of data that they depict. Statistical data are usually characterized by their scale: nominal, ordinal (which are both categorical) or numerical (which is usually regarded as continuous). What is most important in distinguishing statistical graphics from other graphics is their universality: statistical graphics are not tailored towards only one specific application but are valid for any data measured on the appropriate scales." (Antony Unwin et al [in "Graphics of Large Datasets: Visualizing a Million"], 2006)

"Oftentimes a statistical graphic provides the evidence for a plausible story, and the evidence, though perhaps only circumstantial, can be quite convincing. […] But such graphical arguments are not always valid. Knowledge of the underlying phenomena and additional facts may be required." (Howard Wainer, "Graphic Discovery: A trout in the milk and other visuals" 2nd, 2008)

"Placing a fact within a context increases its value greatly. […] . An efficacious way to add context to statistical facts is by embedding them in a graphic. Sometimes the most helpful context is geographical, and shaded maps come to mind as examples. Sometimes the most helpful context is temporal, and time-based line graphs are the obvious choice. But how much time? The ending date (today) is usually clear, but where do you start? The starting point determines the scale. […] The starting point and hence the scale are determined by the questions that we expect the graph to answer." (Howard Wainer, "Graphic Discovery: A trout in the milk and other visuals" 2nd, 2008)

"Eye-catching data graphics tend to use designs that are unique (or nearly so) without being strongly focused on the data being displayed. In the world of Infovis, design goals can be pursued at the expense of statistical goals. In contrast, default statistical graphics are to a large extent determined by the structure of the data (line plots for time series, histograms for univariate data, scatterplots for bivariate nontime-series data, and so forth), with various conventions such as putting predictors on the horizontal axis and outcomes on the vertical axis. Most statistical graphs look like other graphs, and statisticians often think this is a good thing." (Andrew Gelman & Antony Unwin, "Infovis and Statistical Graphics: Different Goals, Different Looks" , Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics Vol. 22(1), 2013)

"After all, we do agree that statistical data analysis is concerned with generating and evaluating hypotheses about data. For us, generating hypotheses means that we are searching for patterns in the data - trying to 'see what the data seem to say'. And evaluating hypotheses means that we are seeking an explanation or at least a simple description of what we find - trying to verify what we believe we see." (Forrest W Young et al, "Visual Statistics: Seeing data with dynamic interactive graphics", 2016)

📉Graphical Representation: Confusion (Just the Quotes)

"First, it is generally inadvisable to attempt to portray a series of more than four or five categories by means of pie charts. If, for example, there are six, eight, or more categories, it may be very confusing to differentiate the relative values portrayed, especially if several small sectors are of approximately the same size. Second, the pie chart may lose its effectiveness if an attempt is made to compare the component values of several circles, as might be found in a temporal or geographical series. In such case the one-hundred percent bar or column chart is more appropriate. Third, although the proportionate values portrayed in a pie chart are measured as distances along arcs about the circle, actually there is a tendency to estimate values in terms of areas of sectors or by the size of subtended angles at the center of the circle." (Calvin F Schmid, "Handbook of Graphic Presentation", 1954)

"Percentages offer a fertile field for confusion. And like the ever-impressive decimal they can lend an aura of precision to the inexact. […] Any percentage figure based on a small number of cases is likely to be misleading. It is more informative to give the figure itself. And when the percentage is carried out to decimal places, you begin to run the scale from the silly to the fraudulent." (Darell Huff, "How to Lie with Statistics", 1954)

"The eye can accurately appraise only very few features of a diagram, and consequently a complicated or confusing diagram will lead the reader astray. The fundamental rule for all charting is to use a plan which is simple and which takes account, in its arrangement of the facts to be presented, of the above-mentioned capacities of the eye."  (William L Crum et al, "Introduction to Economic Statistics", 1938)

"Besides being easier to construct than a bar chart, the line chart possesses other advantages. It is easier to read, for while the bars stand out more prominently than the line, they tend to become confusing if numerous, and especially so when they record alternate increase and decrease. It is easier for the eye to follow a line across the face of the chart than to jump from bar top to bar top, and the slope of the line connecting two points is a great aid in detecting minor changes. The line is also more suggestive of movement than arc bars, and movement is the very essence of a time series. Again, a line chart permits showing two or more related variables on the same chart, or the same variable over two or more corresponding periods." (Walter E Weld, "How to Chart; Facts from Figures with Graphs", 1959)

"If two or more data paths ate to appear on the graph, it is essential that these lines be labeled clearly, or at least a reference should be provided for the reader to make the necessary identifications. While clarity seems to be a most obvious goal, graphs with inadequate or confusing labeling do appear in publications, The user should not find identification of data paths troublesome or subject to misunderstanding. The designer normally should place no more than three data paths on the graph to prevent confusion - particularly if the data paths intersect at one or more points on the Cartesian plane." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"The information on a plot should be relevant to the goals of the analysis. This means that in choosing graphical methods we should match the capabilities of the methods to our needs in the context of each application. [...] Scatter plots, with the views carefully selected as in draftsman's displays, casement displays, and multiwindow plots, are likely to be more informative. We must be careful, however, not to confuse what is relevant with what we expect or want to find. Often wholly unexpected phenomena constitute our most important findings." (John M Chambers et al, "Graphical Methods for Data Analysis", 1983)

"Confusion and clutter are failures of design, not attributes of information. And so the point is to find design strategies that reveal detail and complexity - rather than to fault the data for an excess of complication. Or, worse, to fault viewers for a lack of understanding. Among the most powerful devices for reducing noise and enriching the content of displays is the technique of layering and separation, visually stratifying various aspects of the data." (Edward R Tufte, "Envisioning Information", 1990)

"What about confusing clutter? Information overload? Doesn't data have to be ‘boiled down’ and  ‘simplified’? These common questions miss the point, for the quantity of detail is an issue completely separate from the difficulty of reading. Clutter and confusion are failures of design, not attributes of information. Often the less complex and less subtle the line, the more ambiguous and less interesting is the reading. Stripping the detail out of data is a style based on personal preference and fashion, considerations utterly indifferent to substantive content." (Edward R Tufte, "Envisioning Information", 1990)

"Grouped area graphs sometimes cause confusion because the viewer cannot determine whether the areas for the data series extend down to the zero axis. […] Grouped area graphs can handle negative values somewhat better than stacked area graphs but they still have the problem of all or portions of data curves being hidden by the data series towards the front." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996)

"Technically, there is no limit as to the number of data series that can be plotted on a single graph. Practically, if the number goes above three or four the graph becomes confusing." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996)

"When it comes to drawing a picture of continuous data, you need to think through carefully where one interval ends and the next one begins. Failing to do this can result in overlaps or gaps between adjacent intervals, which can cause confusion." (Alan Graham, "Developing Thinking in Statistics", 2006)

"Arbitrary category sequence and misplaced pie chart emphasis lead to general confusion and weaken messages. Although this can be used for quite deliberate and targeted deceit, manipulation of the category axis only really comes into its own with techniques that bend the relationship between the data and the optics in a more calculated way. Many of these techniques are just twins of similar ruses on the value axis. but are none the less powerful for that." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"Using colour, itʼs possible to increase the density of information even further. A single colour can be used to represent two variables simultaneously. The difficulty, however, is that there is a limited amount of information that can be packed into colour without confusion." (Brian Suda, "A Practical Guide to Designing with Data", 2010)

"Bear in mind is that the use of color doesn’t always help. Use it sparingly and with a specific purpose in mind. Remember that the reader’s brain is looking for patterns, and will expect both recurrence itself and the absence of expected recurrence to carry meaning. If you’re using color to differentiate categorical data, then you need to let the reader know what the categories are. If the dimension of data you’re encoding isn’t significant enough to your message to be labeled or explained in some way - or if there is no dimension to the data underlying your use of difference colors - then you should limit your use so as not to confuse the reader." (Noah Iliinsky & Julie Steel, "Designing Data Visualizations", 2011)

"Graphs should not be mere decoration, to amuse the easily bored. A useful graph displays data accurately and coherently, and helps us understand the data. Chartjunk, in contrast, distracts, confuses, and annoys. Chartjunk may be well-intentioned, but it is misguided. It may also be a deliberate attempt to mystify." (Gary Smith, "Standard Deviations", 2014)

"Uncertainty confuses many people because they have the unreasonable expectation that science and statistics will unearth precise truths, when all they can yield is imperfect estimates that can always be subject to changes and updates." (Alberto Cairo, "How Charts Lie", 2019)

"Bad complexity neither elucidates important salient points nor shows coherent broader trends. It will obfuscate, frustrate, tax the mind, and ultimately convey trendlessness and confusion to the viewer. Good complexity, in contrast, emerges from visualizations that use more data than humans can reasonably process to form a few salient points." (Scott Berinato, "Good Charts : the HBR guide to making smarter, more persuasive data visualizations", 2023)

📉Graphical Representation: Groups (Just the Quotes)

"Bar-charts are most flexible and can be varied to suit the individual whims of the maker. In general, however, there is one style or form which will be found most satisfactory. It consists of a horizontal grouping of bars alongside of the data. The chart is arranged in tabular form, with items or stubs in  a column to the left, with figures in a column beside the stubs and with bars in a column beside the figures. Several columns of figures are sometimes desirable, just as in the table of data, to show sources or original figures from which the charted figures are obtained. In any case, the bars should represent the most important set or column of figures, and there should be normally but one column of bars."(Karl G Karsten, "Charts and Graphs", 1925)

"Pencil and paper for construction of distributions, scatter diagrams, and run-charts to compare small groups and to detect trends are more efficient methods of estimation than statistical inference that depends on variances and standard errors, as the simple techniques preserve the information in the original data." (William E Deming, "On Probability as Basis for Action" American Statistician Vol. 29 (4), 1975)

"The basic principle which should be observed in designing tables is that of grouping related data, either by the use of space or, if necessary, rules. Items which are close together will be seen as being more closely related than items which are farther apart, and the judicious use of space is therefore vitally important. Similarly, ruled lines can be used to relate and divide information, and it is important to be sure which function is required. Rules should not be used to create closed compartments; this is time-wasting and it interferes with scanning." (Linda Reynolds & Doig Simmonds, "Presentation of Data in Science" 4th Ed, 1984)

"The space between columns, on the other hand, should be just sufficient to separate them clearly, but no more. The columns should not, under any circumstances, be spread out merely to fill the width of the type area. […] Sometimes, however, it is difficult to avoid undesirably large gaps between columns, particularly where the data within any given column vary considerably in length. This problem can sometimes be solved by reversing the order of the columns […]. In other instances the insertion of additional space after every fifth entry or row can be helpful, […] but care must be taken not to imply that the grouping has any special meaning." (Linda Reynolds & Doig Simmonds, "Presentation of Data in Science" 4th Ed, 1984)

"Scatter charts show the relationships between information, plotted as points on a grid. These groupings can portray general features of the source data, and are useful for showing where correlationships occur frequently. Some scatter charts connect points of equal value to produce areas within the grid which consist of similar features." (Bruce Robertson, "How to Draw Charts & Diagrams", 1988)

"A good chart delineates and organizes information. It communicates complex ideas, procedures, and lists of facts by simplifying, grouping, and setting and marking priorities. By spatial organization, it should lead the eye through information smoothly and efficiently." (Mary H Briscoe, "Preparing Scientific Illustrations: A guide to better posters, presentations, and publications" 2nd ed., 1995)

"Grouped area graphs sometimes cause confusion because the viewer cannot determine whether the areas for the data series extend down to the zero axis. […] Grouped area graphs can handle negative values somewhat better than stacked area graphs but they still have the problem of all or portions of data curves being hidden by the data series towards the front." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996)

"When analyzing data it is many times advantageous to generate a variety of graphs using the same data. This is true whether there is little or lots of data. Reasons for this are: (1) Frequently, all aspects of a group of data can not be displayed on a single graph. (2) Multiple graphs generally result in a more in-depth understanding of the information. (3) Different aspects of the same data often become apparent. (4) Some types of graphs cause certain features of the data to stand out better (5) Some people relate better to one type of graph than another." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996) 

"If you want to hide data, try putting it into a larger group and then use the average of the group for the chart. The basis of the deceit is the endearingly innocent assumption on the part of your readers that you have been scrupulous in using a representative average: one from which individual values do not deviate all that much. In scientific or statistical circles, where audiences tend to take less on trust, the 'quality' of the average (in terms of the scatter of the underlying individual figures) is described by the standard deviation, although this figure is itself an average." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"We tend automatically to think of all the categories represented on the horizontal axis of a column Chart as being equally important. They vary of course on the value axis. Otherwise, there would be little point in the chart, but there is somehow this feeling that they are in other respects similar members of a group. This convention can be put to good use to manipulate the message of the most boring bar or column chart." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"Where there is no natural ordering to the categories it can be helpful to order them by size, as this can help you to pick out any patterns or compare the relative frequencies across groups. As it can be difficult to discern immediately the numbers represented in each of the categories it is good practice to include the number of observations on which the chart is based, together with the percentages in each category." (Jenny Freeman et al, "How to Display Data", 2008)

"Grouping charts according to a theme and in sequence with the message and putting them all on the same sheet or slide helps you find the thread of the message (even if the charts are separated again later)." (Jorge Camões, "Data at Work: Best practices for creating effective charts and information graphics in Microsoft Excel", 2016)

"The law of connectivity tells us that objects connected to other objects tend to be seen as a group. […] The law of common fate tells us that objects moving in the same direction are seen as a group."  (Jorge Camões, "Data at Work: Best practices for creating effective charts and information graphics in Microsoft Excel", 2016)

"The law of continuity states that we interpret images so as not to generate abrupt transitions or otherwise create images that are more complex. […] we can arbitrarily fill in the missing elements to complete a pattern. It’s also the case of time series, in which we assume that data points in the future will be a smooth continuation of the past. […] In a line chart, those series with a similar slope (that is, they appear to follow the same direction) are understood as belonging to the same group." (Jorge Camões, "Data at Work: Best practices for creating effective charts and information graphics in Microsoft Excel", 2016)

"The law of segregation tells us that objects within a closed shape are seen as a group. A frame around objects (charts or legends, for example) has this function, but it’s also useful for adding visual annotations."  (Jorge Camões, "Data at Work: Best practices for creating effective charts and information graphics in Microsoft Excel", 2016)

"A histogram represents the frequency distribution of the data. Histograms are similar to bar charts but group numbers into ranges. Also, a histogram lets you show the frequency distribution of continuous data. This helps in analyzing the distribution (for example, normal or Gaussian), any outliers present in the data, and skewness." (Umesh R Hodeghatta & Umesha Nayak, "Business Analytics Using R: A Practical Approach", 2017)

"Another problem is that while data visualizations may appear to be objective, the designer has a great deal of control over the message a graphic conveys. Even using accurate data, a designer can manipulate how those data make us feel. She can create the illusion of a correlation where none exists, or make a small difference between groups look big." (Carl T Bergstrom & Jevin D West, "Calling Bullshit: The Art of Skepticism in a Data-Driven World", 2020)

📉Graphical Representation: Mosaic Plots (Just the Quotes)

"We have so consistently inveighed against the use of areas to illustrate quantities that the reader will indeed be surprised at some coming retractions. [...] But the fact is that we now propose to turn to advantage the very feature of areas which has previously been their greatest fault. [...] We now come to data in which we wish to show simultaneously three ratios or sets of ratios, one of which is always the product of the other two. In other words, we wish to show two factors or sets of factors and their product." (Karl Karsten, "Charts and Graphs", 1925)

"A contingency table specifies the joint distribution of a number of discrete variables. The numbers in a contingency table are represented by rectangles of areas proportional to the numbers, with shape and position chosen to expose deviations from independence models. The collection of rectangles for the contingency table is called a mosaic." (John A Hartigan & B Kleiner, "Mosaics for Contingency Tables", 1981)

"Mosaic displays represent the counts in a contingency table by tiles whose size is proportional to the cell count. This graphical display for categorical data generalizes readily to multiway tables."  (Michael Friendly, "Mosaic Displays for Loglinear Models", Proceedings of the Statistical Graphics, 1992)

"Although the basic mosaic display shows the data in any contingency table, it does not in general provide a visual representation of the fit of the data to a specified model. In the two-way case independence is shown when the tiles in each row align vertically, but visual assessment of other models is more difficult." (Michael Friendly, "Mosaic Displays for Loglinear Models", Proceedings of the Statistical Graphics, 1992)

"Categorical data are most often modeled using loglinear models. For certain loglinear models, mosaic plots have unique shapes that do not depend on the actual data being modeled. These shapes reflect the structure of a model, defined by the presence and absence of particular model coefficients. Displaying the expected values of a loglinear model allows one to incorporate the residuals of the model graphically and to visually judge the adequacy of the loglinear fit. This procedure leads to stepwise interactive graphical modeling of loglinear models. We show that it often results in a deeper understanding of the structure of the data. Linking mosaic plots to other inter- active displays offers additional power that allows the investigation of more complex dependence models than provided by static displays." (Martin Theus & Stephan R W Lauer, "Visualizing Loglinear Models", Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics Vol. 8 (3), 1999)

"The scatterplot matrix shows all pairwise (bivariate marginal) views of a set of variables in a coherent display. One analog for categorical data is a matrix of mosaic displays showing some aspect of the bivariate relation between all pairs of variables. The simplest case shows the bivariate marginal relation for each pair of variables. Another case shows the conditional relation between each pair, with all other variables partialled out. For quantitative data this represents (a) a visualization of the conditional independence relations studied by graphical models, and (b) a generalization of partial residual plots. The conditioning plot, or coplot, shows a collection of partial views of several quantitative variables, conditioned by the values of one or more other variables. A direct analog of the coplot for categorical data is an array of mosaic plots of the dependence among two or more variables, stratified by the values of one or more given variables. Each such panel then shows the partial associations among the foreground variables; the collection of such plots shows how these associations change as the given variables vary." (Michael Friendly, "Extending Mosaic Displays: Marginal, Conditional, and Partial Views of Categorical Data", 199)

"A graphical display of a p-dimensional contingency table, the empirical distribution of p categorical variables, is a mosaic plot. Each tile (or bin) corresponds to one cell of the contingency table, its size to the number of the cell's entries. The shape of a tile is calculated during the (strictly hierarchical) construction." (Heike Hoffmann, "Generalized Odds Ratios for Visual Modeling", Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics Vol. 10 (4), 2001)

"Mosaics are space-filling designs composed of contiguous shapes ('tiles')." (Michael Friendly, "A Brief History of the Mosaic Display", Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, Vol. 11 (1), 2002)

"The principal graphical ideas [of mosaic plots] are: (*) using area = height x width, to represent a quantity which depends on a product of two other variables, each of interest; (*) using recursive subsdivision to show any number of variables; (*) using shading to display some other attribute of the data; (*) purely multiplicative relations (e.g., Pij = Pi+P+j) produce equal subdivisions; (*) for two or more variables, the levels of subdivision are spaced with larger gaps at the earlier levels, to allow easier perception of the groupings at various levels, and to provide for empty cells." (Michael Friendly, "A Brief History of the Mosaic Display", Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, Vol. 11 (1), 2002)

"Mosaic plots […] are designed to show the dependencies and interactions between multiple categorical variables in one plot. […] A spineplot can be regarded as a kind of one-dimensional mosaic plot. […] In contrast with a barchart, where the bars are aligned to an axis, the mosaic plot uses a rectangular region, which is subdivided into tiles according to the numbers of observations falling into the different classes. This subdivision is done recursively, or in statistical terms conditionally, as more variables are included." (Antony Unwin et al [in "Graphics of Large Datasets: Visualizing a Million"], 2006)

"Due to their recursive definition, switching the order of variables in a mosaic plot has a strong impact on what can be read from the plot. For instance, exchanging the two variables in a two-dimensional mosaic plot results in a completely new plot rather than in a mere graphically transposed version of the original plot." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009)  

"Mosaic plots are defined recursively, i.e., each variable that is introduced in a mosaic plot is plotted conditioned on the groups already established in the plot. As with barcharts, the area of bars or tiles is proportional to the number of observations (or the sum of the observation weights of a class). The direction along which bars are divided by a newly introduced variable is usually alternating, starting with the x-direction." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009) 

"Mosaic plots become more difficult to read for variables with more than two or three categories. One way out is to assign a constant space for all possible crossings of categories. This way, the data from the r×c table are plotted in a table-like layout. Whereas this regular layout makes it much easier to compare values across rows and columns, the plot space is used less efficiently than in a mosaic plot." (Martin Theus & Simon Urbanek, "Interactive Graphics for Data Analysis: Principles and Examples", 2009)

"Conceptually, mosaic plots for s + 1 factors in strength s designs can be used for any s; in practice, the idea is limited by space constraints, especially for accommodating labels for the factor levels. All four margins are used for four-factor projections; with the next dimension, one margin has to be used for two factors. In practice, one will rarely consider mosaic plots for more factors than four at a time." (Ulrike Grömping, "Mosaic Plots are Useful for Visualizing Low-Order Projections of Factorial Designs", The American Statistician Vol. 68 (2), 2014)

"Mosaic plots are particularly useful for design and analysis of orthogonal main effect plans. [...] mosaic plots do not reflect geometric properties relevant for designs in quantitative factors. Nevertheless, mosaic plots can also be used to visualize founding severity for designs with quantitative factors [...]" (Ulrike Grömping, "Mosaic Plots are Useful for Visualizing Low-Order Projections of Factorial Designs", The American Statistician Vol. 68 (2), 2014)

"Mosaic plots can get quite messy when increasing the number of variables, which is presumably the reason many commercial software products offer them for two variables only." (Ulrike Grömping, "Mosaic Plots are Useful for Visualizing Low-Order Projections of Factorial Designs", The American Statistician Vol. 68 (2), 2014)

"The rectangular treemap, sometimes called the mosaic graph, is a space-filling visualization model used for displaying hierarchical data by means of nested rectangles. Each major branch of the tree is depicted as a rectangle, which is then sequentially tiled with smaller rectangles representing its subbranches. The area of each individual cell generally corresponds to a given quantity or data attri bute, for example size, length, price, time, or temperature. Color can indicate an additional quality, such as type, class, gender, or category." (Manuel Lima, "The Book of Trees: Visualizing Branches of Knowledge", 2014)

"The way that the model differs from the data gives us clues about how we can improve our model. We can use mosaic displays to find the specific ways in which the model is different from the data, since mosaics show the residuals (or differences) of the cells with respect to the model. Looking at these differences, we can observe patterns in the deviation that will help us in our search." (Forrest W Young et al, "Visual Statistics: Seeing data with dynamic interactive graphics", 2016)

📉Graphical Representation: Relations (Just the Quotes)

"There is no doubt that graphical expression will soon replace all others whenever one has at hand a movement or change of state - in a word, any phenomenon. Born before science, language is often inappropriate to express exact measures or definite relations." (Étienne-Jules Marey, "La méthode graphique dans les sciences expérimentales et principalement en physiologie et en médecine", 1878)

"[...] we can not readily break up a complicated problem into successive steps which can be taken independently. We have, in fact, to solve the problem first, by determining what are the actual mutual relations of the classes involved, and then to draw the circles to represent this final result; we cannot work step-by-step towards the conclusion by aid of our figures." (John Venn, "On the Diagrammatic and Mechanical Representation of Propositions and Reasonings", 1880)

"[…] it must be noticed that these diagrams do not naturally harmonize with the propositions of ordinary life or ordinary logic. […] The great bulk of the propositions which we commonly meet with are founded, and rightly founded, on an imperfect knowledge of the actual mutual relations of the implied classes to one another. […] one very marked characteristic about these circular diagrams is that they forbid the natural expression of such uncertainty, and are therefore only directly applicable to a very small number of such propositions as we commonly meet with." (John Venn, "On the Diagrammatic and Mechanical Representation of Propositions and Reasonings", 1880)

"Whereas the Eulerian plan endeavoured at once and directly to represent propositions, or relations of class terms to one another, we shall find it best to begin by representing only classes, and then proceed to modify these in some way so as to make them indicate what our propositions have to say. How, then, shall we represent all the subclasses which two or more class terms can produce? Bear in mind that what we have to indicate is the successive duplication of the number of subdivisions produced by the introduction of each successive term. and we shall see our way to a very important departure from the Eulerian conception. All that we have to do is to draw our figures, say circles, so that each successive one which we introduce shall intersect once, and once only, all the subdivisions already existing, and we then have what may be called a general framework indicating every possible combination producible by the given class terms." (John Venn, "On the Diagrammatic and Mechanical Representation of Propositions and Reasonings", 1880)

"[…] deduction consists in constructing an icon or diagram the relations of whose parts shall present a complete analogy with those of the parts of the object of reasoning, of experimenting upon this image in the imagination, and of observing the result so as to discover unnoticed and hidden relations among the parts." (Charles S Peirce, 1885)

"Deduction is that mode of reasoning which examines the state of things asserted in the premises, forms a diagram of that state of things, perceives in the parts of the diagram relations not explicitly mentioned in the premises, satisfies itself by mental experiments upon the diagram that these relations would always subsist, or at least would do so in a certain proportion of cases, and concludes their necessary, or probable, truth." (Charles S Peirce, "Kinds of Reasoning", cca. 1896)

"Statistics are numerical statements of facts in any department of inquiry, placed in relation to each other; statistical methods are devices for abbreviating and classifying the statements and making clear the relations." (Arthur L Bowley, "An Elementary Manual of Statistics", 1934)

"Although the pie or sector chart ranks very high in popular appeal, it is held in rather low esteem by many specialists in graphic presentation. Since the pie chart possesses more weaknesses perhaps than most graphic forms, it is especially important to observe proper discretion in its construction and application. The pie chart is used to portray component relations. The various sectors of a circle represent component parts of an aggregate or total." (Calvin F Schmid, "Handbook of Graphic Presentation", 1954)

"A system may be specified in either of two ways. In the first, which we shall call a state description, sets of abstract inputs, outputs and states are given, together with the action of the inputs on the states and the assignments of outputs to states. In the second, which we shall call a coordinate description, certain input, output and state variables are given, together with a system of dynamical equations describing the relations among the variables as functions of time. Modern mathematical system theory is formulated in terms of state descriptions, whereas the classical formulation is typically a coordinate description, for example a system of differential equations." (E S Bainbridge, "The Fundamental Duality of System Theory", 1975)

"If you want to dramatize comparisons in relation to the whole. use a pie chart. If you want to add coherence to the narrative, the pie chart also helps because it depicts a whole. If your main interest is in stressing the relationship of one factor to another, use bar charts. If you wish to achieve all these effects. you can use either type of chart. and decide on the basis of which one is more aesthetically or pictorially interesting." (Robert Lefferts, "Elements of Graphics: How to prepare charts and graphs for effective reports", 1981)

"In order to be easily understood, a display of information must have a logical structure which is appropriate for the user's knowledge and needs, and this structure must be clearly represented visually. In order to indicate structure, it is necessary to be able to eemphasiz, divide and relate items of information. Visual emphasis can be used to indicate a hierarchical relationship between items of information, as in the case of systems of headings and subheadings for example. Visual separation of items can be used to indicate that they are different in kind or are unrelated functionally, and similarly a visual relationship between items will imply that they are of a similar kind or bear some functional relation to one another. This kind of visual 'coding' helps the reader to appreciate the extent and nature of the relationship between items of information, and to adopt an appropriate scanning strategy." (Linda Reynolds & Doig Simmonds, "Presentation of Data in Science" 4th Ed, 1984)

📉Graphical Representation: Circles (Just the Quotes)

"Comparison between circles of different size should be absolutely avoided. It is inexcusable when we have available simple methods of charting so good and so convenient from every point of view as the horizontal bar." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"In general, the comparison of two circles of different size should be strictly avoided. Many excellent works on statistics approve the comparison of circles of different size, and state that the circles should always be drawn to represent the facts on an area basis rather than on a diameter basis. The rule, however, is not always followed and the reader has no way of telling whether the circles compared have been drawn on a diameter basis or on an area basis, unless the actual figures for the data are given so that the dimensions may be verified." (Willard C Brinton, "Graphic Methods for Presenting Facts", 1919)

"A circular, like a square, area varies with the square of its linear measurements. If you make the radius of one circle twice as great as the radius of the other, the first area will be four times as great as the first. If you make the areas proportionate, the radii must be in the relation of 1 to the square root of 2. Both circle and square require the more or less tedious computation of square roots and repay this labor with inaccurate and ambiguous results." (Karl G Karsten, "Charts and Graphs", 1925) 

"Although the pie or sector chart ranks very high in popular appeal, it is held in rather low esteem by many specialists in graphic presentation. Since the pie chart possesses more weaknesses perhaps than most graphic forms, it is especially important to observe proper discretion in its construction and application. The pie chart is used to portray component relations. The various sectors of a circle represent component parts of an aggregate or total." (Calvin F Schmid, "Handbook of Graphic Presentation", 1954)

"First, it is generally inadvisable to attempt to portray a series of more than four or five categories by means of pie charts. If, for example, there are six, eight, or more categories, it may be very confusing to differentiate the relative values portrayed, especially if several small sectors are of approximately the same size. Second, the pie chart may lose its effectiveness if an attempt is made to compare the component values of several circles, as might be found in a temporal or geographical series. In such case the one-hundred percent bar or column chart is more appropriate. Third, although the proportionate values portrayed in a pie chart are measured as distances along arcs about the circle, actually there is a tendency to estimate values in terms of areas of sectors or by the size of subtended angles at the center of the circle." (Calvin F Schmid, "Handbook of Graphic Presentation", 1954)

"Circles of different size, however cannot properly be used to compare the size of different totals. This is because the reader does not know whether to compare the diameters or the areas" (which vary as the squares of the diameters), and is likely to misjudge the comparison in either ease. Usually the circles are drawn so that their diameters are in correct proportion to each other; but then the area comparison is exaggerated. Component bars should be used to show totals of different size since their one dimension lengths can be easily judged not only for the totals themselves but for the component parts as well. Circles, therefore, can show proportions properly by variations in angles of sectors but not by variations in diameters. " (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"Pie charts have weaknesses and dangers inherent in their design and application. First, it is generally inadvisable to attempt to portray more than four or five categories in a circle chart, especially if several small sectors are of approximately the same size.  It may be very confusing to differentiate the relative values. Secondly, the pie chart loses effectiveness if an effort is made to compare the component values of several circles, as might occur in a temporal or geographical series. [...] Thirdly, although values are measured by distances along the arc of the circle, there is a tendency to estimate values in terms of areas by size of angle. The 100-percent bar chart is often preferable to the circle chart's angle and area comparison as it is easier to divide into parts, more convenient to use, has sections that may be shaded for contrast with grouping possible by bracketing, and has an easily readable percentage scale outside the bars." (Anna C Rogers, "Graphic Charts Handbook", 1961)

"Data should not be forced into an uncomfortable or improper mold. For example, data that is appropriate for line graphs is not usually appropriate for circle charts and in any case not without some arithmetic transformation. Only graphs that are designed to fit the data can be used profitably." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"In certain respects, line graphs are uniquely applicable to particular graphic requirements for which a bar or circle chart could not be substituted. Strictly speaking, the line graph must be used to portray changes in a continuous variable, since technically such a variable must be represented by a line and not by 'points' or 'bars'. Line graphs are often uniquely applicable to problems of analysis, particularly when it is essential to visualize a trend, observe the behavior of a set of variables through time, or portray the same variable in differing time periods." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"The varieties of circle charts are necessarily limited by the lack of basic design variation - a circle is a circle! Also, a circle can be considered as representing only one unit of area. regardless of its size. Thus, circle charts have limited applications, i.e., to show how a given quantity" (area) is divided among its component parts,' or to show changes in the variable by showing area changes. A circle chart almost always presents some form of a part-to-total relationship." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

"While circle charts are not likely to present especially new or creative ideas, they do help the user to visualize relationships. The relationships depicted by circle charts do not tend to be very complex, in contrast to those of some line graphs. Normally, the circle chart is used to portray a common type of relationship" (namely. part-to-total) in an attractive manner and to expedite the message transfer from designer to user." (Cecil H Meyers, "Handbook of Basic Graphs: A modern approach", 1970)

A pie graph is a circle that is divided into wedges, like slices of a pie. It is particularly useful when statistics show as a half or a quarter of a total. The human eye can recognize half of a circle much more easily than half a length of a bar." (Dyno Lowenstein, "Graphs", 1976)

The circle graph, or pie chart, appears to simple and 'nonstatistical', so it is a popular form of presentation for general readers. However, since the eye can compare linear distances more easily and accurately than angles or areas, the component parts of a total usually can be shown more effectively in a chart using linear measurement." (Peter H Selby, "Interpreting Graphs and Tables", 1976)

A pie chart is comprised of a circle that is divided into segments by straight lines within the circle. The circle represents the total or whole amount. Each segment or wedge of the circle represents the proportion that a particular factor is of the total or whole amount. Thus, a pie chart in its entirety always represents whole amounts of either 100% or a total absolute number, such as 100 cents or 5,000 people. All of the segments of the pie when taken together" (that is, in the aggregate) must add up to the total." (Robert Lefferts, "Elements of Graphics: How to prepare charts and graphs for effective reports", 1981)

"Visual thinking can begin with the three basic shapes we all learned to draw before kindergarten: the triangle, the circle, and the square. The triangle encourages you to rank parts of a problem by priority. When drawn into a triangle, these parts are less likely to get out of order and take on more importance than they should. While the triangle ranks, the circle encloses and can be used to include and/or exclude. Some problems have to be enclosed to be managed. Finally, the square serves as a versatile problem-solving tool. By assigning it attributes along its sides or corners, we can suddenly give a vague issue a specific place to live and to move about." (Terry Richey, "The Marketer's Visual Tool Kit", 1994)

"Two types of graphic organizers are commonly used for comparison: the Venn diagram and the comparison matrix [...] the Venn diagram provides students with a visual display of the similarities and differences between two items. The similarities between elements are listed in the intersection between the two circles. The differences are listed in the parts of each circle that do not intersect. Ideally, a new Venn diagram should be completed for each characteristic so that students can easily see how similar and different the elements are for each characteristic used in the comparison." (Robert J. Marzano et al, "Classroom Instruction that Works: Research-based strategies for increasing student achievement, 2001)

"Radar charts are almost always the result either of space-saving attempts or of doubtful theories about the desirability of 'symmetrical' plots, in which scores on all dimensions are similar, so giving an approximation to a circle. Their scales offer unlimited scope for manipulation in achieving this lunatic ambition." (Nicholas Strange, "Smoke and Mirrors: How to bend facts and figures to your advantage", 2007)

"Diagrams are information graphics that are made up primarily of geometric shapes, such as rectangles, circles, diamonds, or triangles, that are typically" (but not always) interconnected by lines or arrows. One of the major purposes of a diagram is to show how things, people, ideas, activities, etc. interrelate and interconnect. Unlike quantitative charts and graphs, diagrams are used to show interrelationships in a qualitative way." (Robbie T Nakatsu, "Diagrammatic Reasoning in AI", 2010)

"Area can also make data seem more tangible or relatable, because physical objects take up space. A circle or a square uses more space than a dot on a screen or paper. There’s less abstraction between visual cue and real world." (Nathan Yau, "Data Points: Visualization That Means Something", 2013)

"Circles are among the most ubiquitous symbols around the globe, used in countless variations since the birth of humankind. Associated with notions of unity, wholeness, and infinity, the circle has been an important visual metaphor in a wide array of systems of thought, from cartography and astronomy to physics and geometry. " (Manuel Lima, "The Book of Trees: Visualizing Branches of Knowledge", 2014)

"Standard graphs, like bar and line charts, are so common because they are perceptually more accurate, familiar to people, and easy to create. Nonstandard graphs - those that use circles or curves, for instance - may not allow the reader to most accurately perceive the exact data values. But perceptual accuracy is not always the goal. And sometimes it's not a goal at all. Spurring readers to engage with a graph is sometimes just as important. Sometimes, it's more important. And nonstandard chart types may do just that. In some cases, nonstandard graphs may help show underlying patterns and trends in better ways that standard graphs. In other cases, the fact that these nonstandard graphs are different may make them more engaging, which we may sometimes need to first attract attention to the visualization."  (Jonathan Schwabish, "Better Data Visualizations: A guide for scholars, researchers, and wonks", 2021)

"The radial bar chart, also called the polar bar chart, arranges the bars to radiate outward from the center of a circle. This graph lies lowers on the perceptual ranking list because it is harder to compare the heights of the bars arranged around a circle than when they are arranged along a single flat axis. But this layout does allow you to fit more values in a compact space, and makes the radial bar chart well-suited for showing more data, frequent changes (such as monthly or daily), or changes over a long period of time." (Jonathan Schwabish, "Better Data Visualizations: A guide for scholars, researchers, and wonks", 2021)

📉Graphical Representation: Problems (Just the Quotes)

"Graphic methods are very commonly used in business correlation problems. On the whole, carefully handled and skillfully interpreted graphs have certain advantages over mathematical methods of determining correlation in the usual business problems. The elements of judgment and special knowledge of conditions can be more easily introduced in studying correlation graphically. Mathematical correlation is often much too rigid for the data at hand." (John R Riggleman & Ira N Frisbee, "Business Statistics", 1938)

"One of the greatest values of the graphic chart is its use in the analysis of a problem. Ordinarily, the chart brings up many questions which require careful consideration and further research before a satisfactory conclusion can be reached. A properly drawn chart gives a cross-section picture of the situation. While charts may bring out hidden facts in tables or masses of data, they cannot take the place of careful, analysis. In fact, charts may be dangerous devices when in the hands of those unwilling to base their interpretations upon careful study. This, however, does not detract from their value when they are properly used as aids in solving statistical problems." (John R Riggleman & Ira N Frisbee, "Business Statistics", 1938)

"90 percent of all problems can be solved by using the techniques of data stratification, histograms, and control charts. Among the causes of nonconformance, only one-fifth or less are attributable to the workers." (Kaoru Ishikawa, The Quality Management Journal Vol. 1, 1993)

"Visual thinking can begin with the three basic shapes we all learned to draw before kindergarten: the triangle, the circle, and the square. The triangle encourages you to rank parts of a problem by priority. When drawn into a triangle, these parts are less likely to get out of order and take on more importance than they should. While the triangle ranks, the circle encloses and can be used to include and/or exclude. Some problems have to be enclosed to be managed. Finally, the square serves as a versatile problem-solving tool. By assigning it attributes along its sides or corners, we can suddenly give a vague issue a specific place to live and to move about." (Terry Richey, "The Marketer's Visual Tool Kit", 1994)

"When visualization tools act as a catalyst to early visual thinking about a relatively unexplored problem, neither the semantics nor the pragmatics of map signs is a dominant factor. On the other hand, syntactics (or how the sign-vehicles, through variation in the visual variables used to construct them, relate logically to one another) are of critical importance." (Alan M MacEachren, "How Maps Work: Representation, Visualization, and Design", 1995)

"Although in most cases the actual value designated by a bar is determined by the location of the end of the bar, many people associate the length or area of the bar with its value. As long as the scale is linear, starts at zero, is continuous, and the bars are the same width, this presents no problem. When any of these conditions are changed, the potential exists that the graph will be misinterpreted." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996)

"Grouped area graphs sometimes cause confusion because the viewer cannot determine whether the areas for the data series extend down to the zero axis. […] Grouped area graphs can handle negative values somewhat better than stacked area graphs but they still have the problem of all or portions of data curves being hidden by the data series towards the front." (Robert L Harris, "Information Graphics: A Comprehensive Illustrated Reference", 1996)

"Pie charts have severe perceptual problems. Experiments in graphical perception have shown that compared with dot charts, they convey information far less reliably. But if you want to display some data, and perceiving the information is not so important, then a pie chart is fine." (Richard Becker & William S Cleveland," S-Plus Trellis Graphics User's Manual", 1996)

"The ordinary histogram is constructed by binning data on a uniform grid. Although this is probably the most widely used statistical graphic, it is one of the more difficult ones to compute. Several problems arise, including choosing the number of bins (bars) and deciding where to place the cutpoints between bars." (Leland Wilkinson, "The Grammar of Graphics" 2nd Ed., 2005)

"Scatterplots are still the go-to visualization when one is examining relationships between continuous variables. One of the problems with the traditional scatterplot is that all data points are presented as if they are on equal footing. [...] Bubble maps are scatterplots with added dimensions. The most common usage is to add weight to individual data points based on population." (Christopher Lysy, "Developments in Quantitative Data Display and Their Implications for Evaluation", 2013) 

"One of the main problems with the visual approach to statistical data analysis is that it is too easy to generate too many plots: We can easily become totally overwhelmed by the shear number and variety of graphics that we can generate. In a sense, we have been too successful in our goal of making it easy for the user: Many, many plots can be generated, so many that it becomes impossible to understand our data." (Forrest W Young et al, "Visual Statistics: Seeing data with dynamic interactive graphics", 2016)

"One very common problem in data visualization is that encoding numerical variables to area is incredibly popular, but readers can’t translate it back very well." (Robert Grant, "Data Visualization: Charts, Maps and Interactive Graphics", 2019)

"Another problem is that while data visualizations may appear to be objective, the designer has a great deal of control over the message a graphic conveys. Even using accurate data, a designer can manipulate how those data make us feel. She can create the illusion of a correlation where none exists, or make a small difference between groups look big." (Carl T Bergstrom & Jevin D West, "Calling Bullshit: The Art of Skepticism in a Data-Driven World", 2020)

"Whatever approach you take, it’s always a good idea to define a range of reusable colour palettes so you don’t need to face the same colour design problems every time you want to create a chart or map. There will always be exceptions that require a different treatment, but it’s good to have a solid default starting point." (Alan Smith, "How Charts Work: Understand and explain data with confidence", 2022)